thats a pretty vague kwestion, kinda like askin which is better a redhead, er a blonde.....everyones gunna have a different opinion.
_Whats the purpose of the vehicle?
_Which are you more comfortable driving?
_Resale.....(some folks won't consider anything but an auto)
...i'm sure theres a ton more variables but I think #2 is the largest factor.
.
..personally, I love havin 3 peddles, and a stout trouble free unit. If yu decide to do it, I might take that 435 offa yer hands

...
...in my driveway its a split, 4 vehicles with manuals, and 2 with autos.......everything, chevy, ford, dodge, jeep, and toyota.